Skip to Main Content.

Insurance Coverage & Bad Faith

Considered among the foremost legal teams with respect to insurance coverage, fraud and extra-contractual damage cases, we draw on decades of combined experience representing insurance companies in high-stakes litigation. Our attorneys regularly and successfully handle large matters ranging from construction defect and subrogation claims to professional liability, environmental and bad faith litigation. We understand the stakes involved in such cases, particularly when a company’s policies are under direct attack, and we work aggressively to resolve matters with the utmost care and efficiency.

Key Contacts

A person is wearing a dark suit jacket, a light-colored shirt, and a dotted tie, and is smiling against a plain background.
William M. Harter


Columbus, OH

Charleston, WV

A person in a business suit with a red striped tie and a blue checked shirt against a white background.
Douglas W. Langdon


Louisville, KY

David W. Walulik Profile Image
David W. Walulik


Cincinnati, OH

Learn More

Bad Faith Cases

Bad faith cases are critically important to insurance companies because the potential exposure from a punitive damage claim can have a direct and immediate impact on their bottom line. Such cases require a particular skillset, including the ability to analyze complex legal and factual situations. With many years of experience handling insurance coverage claims, we routinely handle cases that involve the following issues:

  • Integrity of sophisticated claims handling procedures
  • Complex coverage issues
  • Attacks on the attorney/client and work product privileges, which are undertaken by plaintiffs in extra-contractual damage cases like no other case
  • Claims for punitive damages
  • Cases which deal with the honesty and integrity of insurance carriers and their representatives
  • Toxic torts

Representative Experience

Our insurance litigation team has extensive experience representing clients in a large number of insurance-related claims, including:

  • Advertising Injury and Personal Injury
  • Assault & Battery Exclusions
  • Arson
  • Bad Faith and Extra-Contractual Litigation
  • Builders Risk Policies
  • Business Interruption Claims
  • Class Action Litigation
  • Commercial Auto Policies
  • Commercial General Liability Insurance Coverage
  • Construction Defect Claims
  • Directors & Officers (D&O)
  • Employment Related Practices Exclusions
  • Environmental Coverage Claims
  • Errors & Omissions
  • Fraud
  • Intellectual Property
  • Manuscript Policies
  • Mold
  • Personal Auto Coverage
  • Professional Liability
  • Property Policies
  • Subrogation Claims
  • Workers’ Compensation

Representative Clients

We represent a broad range of insurance companies and insurance-related serviced providers. The following clients are representative:

  • Liberty Mutual Insurance Group
  • OneBeacon Insurance Group
  • Zurich Insurance Company
  • Encompass Insurance Company
  • The Hartford Insurance Company
  • WV Guaranty Association
  • Nationwide
  • Foremost
  • Electric Insurance Company
  • Great American Insurance Company
  • Farmers Insurance Group
  • National Casualty
  • Western Heritage
  • American International Group (AIG)
  • Cincinnati
  • Northland
  • Protective Life
  • American Home
  • American Safety

Featured Insights

Law and legal advice, regulations and rules for business, labor law concept, layer or notary for company.
Pointers for Handling Appellate Extraordinary Writs

February 23, 2024 | Publications

Appellate extraordinary writs are expedited attempts to overturn or get a different result from a lo...

Closeup of unrecognizable mechanic replacing car brake pads. The car is lifted with hydraulic jack at eye level.
What Upcoming California ‘Lemon Law’ Rulings Could Mean for Manufacturers

January 25, 2024 | Publications

Decisions Could Impact Song-Beverly Act Claims Beyond the Auto Industry With California’s appellat...

Frost Brown Todd Houston Office Adds Partner Mary London Fuller

December 1, 2023 | Press Releases

Practices in the product, tort and insurance space Partner Mary London Fuller is the latest attorney...

What Manufacturers Need to Know About Express Warranties, Arbitration in California

December 1, 2023 | Publications

This article was originally published on The Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act (t...

What to Expect When the Chemical Safety Board Shows Up at Your Plant

October 30, 2023 | Publications

On January 28, 2021, a liquid nitrogen release at the Foundation Food Group’s Prepared Foods Divis...

United States Federal court jury box.
FBT Secures Reversal of $18.2 million Jury Verdict as Kentucky Supreme Court Strengthens Product Lia...

September 7, 2023 | Experience

The Kentucky Supreme Court’s recent decision in Primal Vantage Company, Inc. v. Kevin O’Bryan, e...

States of Disrepair – Recent Developments in the ‘Right to Repair’ Movement

August 28, 2023 | Publications

This article was originally published on  For manufacturers, the growing tractio...

conference room
Overcoming Hurdles to Enforcing Third-Party Subpoenas for Documents in Construction Arbitration

July 26, 2023 | Publications

*This article was originally published in the Summer 2023 edition of the Columbus Bar Association...

FBT logo imposed over electrical towers
Trial Victory: FBT Wins Jury Trial Kentucky Utilities in Wrongful Death Case

February 15, 2023 | Experience

Frost Brown Todd (FBT) defended Kentucky Utilities (KU) in high-stakes litigation involving a 2018 w...

FBT logo imposed over gavel
Trial Victory: FBT Wins Defense Verdict for Liberty Mutual in West Virginia Bad Faith Jury Trial

August 31, 2022 | Experience

Columbus Member Bill Harter and West Chester Practice Support Specialist Amy Carrico won a defense v...

Stay ahead of the law.

Subscribe to receive email updates and choose your topics.